The great blind butter challenge!

feature

Blind butter taste test

We purchased butter from Waitrose (for the wider range) as well as Tesco (who also had some decent imports) from a variety of countries: English, French, Dutch, Irish,Welsh and Italian (unfortunately no Australian or NZ butter was available). The most expensive per weight was the Echire French butter in a basket at £13.80 a kilo or £3.45 per 250g basket. This was followed by the Italian butter, the Beppino Occelli at £1.52 per 125g which was also one of the fanciest in terms of packaging with a rivet seal and an imprint on the butter and instructions on how best to enjoy butters like a connoisseur and details of the 2 awards they won. We also had at the cheapest end, Tesco's English butter. We wanted to try only salted butters (to eliminate the variability when salting a butter yourself) but there were more unsalted butters available so it was a mix. When tasting, we spread them on a freshly baked still-warm crunchy French baguette cut in 1cm thick slices, spread thickly with butter and then sliced up so that each taster got a bit of crust as well as the inside of the bread.

Beppino butter imprint

Beppino Occeli's fancy pants butter

Our lineup:
Step 1 - President lightly salted butter: France £4.76/kg

Step 2 - Beppino Occelli butter: Italy £12.16/kg

Step 3 - Tesco English lightly salted butter: U.K. £3.76/kg

Step 4 - Maydew Kosher unsalted butter: Netherlands

Step 5 - Rachel's Organic lightly salted butter: Wales £5.56/kg

Step 6 - Tesco Brittany butter with sea salt crystals: France £4.08/kg

Step 7 - Bridel Brittany butter: France £6.60/kg

Step 8 - Ste Mere D'Isgny Demi-sel extra fin butter: France £6.48/kg

Step 9 - Goat's Butter: U.K. **£5.16/kg

Step 10 - Yeo valley organic salted butter: U.K. £5.04/kg

Step 11 - West country salted butter: U.K. £5.16/kg

Step 12 - Kerry Gold salted butter: Ireland £4.48/kg

Step 13 - Echire butter: France £13.80

Our tasters:
Step 1 - Blythe

Step 2 - Candy

Step 3 - Kathy

Step 4 - Marc

Step 5 - Mr NQN

I wasn't tasting this as I was administering the test.

Blind butter taste test

The butters ranged in colour, with some markedly paler than others (the Beppino Occelli and Goat's butter were much paler) and some became soft much quicker (the President butter came to room temperature much quicker than the rest). So even before we started, we could see clear differences in both the appearance and texture of the butter. The butters were taken out of the fridge 1 hour prior to consumption to allow them to reach a spreadable temperature.

Each taster cleansed their palette with Perrier in between sampling and were asked to write down any comments they may have and score each butter out of 10 and then give an ordinal score ranking. They were permitted to change the marks once they had tasted them in order to not disadvantage the first butter tasted.

What emerged was very interesting. The butters that had us most intrigued were of course the ones in the fancier packaging or the more expensive. However our tasters resoundly did not prefer these butters ranking them 11th of 13 (Echire from France) and last at 13th (Beppino Occelli). The cheapest butter, Tesco's English butter was also not popular at equal 9th and 10th place.

What also emerged is that on the whole the tasters preferred the French butters overall, however the Echire was one of the least liked, except by Mr NQN. U.K. butters were also judged favourably with the 3rd and 5th most popular being from the U.K. Our tasters were not from the U.K. but from Australia and the U.S.

Best to worst with rating out of 50 and comments:

1st Bridel Brittany salted butter: France (38 out of 50) "strong creamy taste" "salty" "a little oily" "good texture" "strong taste"

2nd Ste Mere D'Isgny Demi-sel extra fin butter: France (33 out of 50) _ "nice creaminess" "creamy" "creamy, 'buttery' taste, no aftertaste"_

3rd Yeo valley organic salted butter: U.K. (32.5 out of 50) "light" "quite rich"

4th Tesco Brittany butter with sea salt crystals: France (32 out of 50) "nice saltiness, a little oily" "creamy" "too salty (taster had a large chunk of sea salt which reduced enjoyment) "creamy butter taste, strong but not overpowering"

5th Goat's unsalted Butter: U.K. (31.5 out of 50) "not much flavour" "light texture and taste" "nice aftertaste"

6th President lightly salted butter: France (31 out of 50) "light moderate taste"

7th Kerry Gold salted butter: Ireland (29 out of 50) "smooth and creamy" "light" "good aftertaste"

8th Rachel's Organic lightly salted butter: Wales (25.5 out of 50) "oily, didn't really like it" "creamy taste, no aftertaste" nicely melted"

9th & 10th (equal) West country salted butter: U.K. "not so much flavour" "light, hint of cream" _& Tesco English lightly salted butter: U.K. (both 25 out of 50) _"smooth" "strong 'butter' taste and strong aftertaste"

11th Echire butter: France (21.5 out of 50) "strong unsalted flavour" "not much taste" "bland"

12th Maydew Kosher unsalted butter: Netherlands (20 out of 50) "smooth unsalted" "light, bland" "bland"

13th/last Beppino Occelli butter: Italy (19 out of 50) "strong flavour, goat's?" "light, different tang" "bland"

*Overall findings: *

Lightly salted or salted butters were more favourably ranked.

Blythe: strong dislike of unsalted butters, preferred salted butters from a variety of countries

Candy: Strong skew towards French butters, ranked all of the French butters highly but also Goat's butter

Kathy: preferred butters from Brittany

Marc: preferred butters from France and the U.K.

Mr NQN: preferred French butters and picked all of the French butters as his favourite

Notes: we would have liked to include Lurpak and Lescure.

Thanks for the fantastic tasters for your enthusiasm for the task and fine palates!