
Hardy Suangin of Harrison’s
It was an offer sent to me via email a few months ago. As soon as I opened it I was instantly intrigued. It involved twenty four meals, six hours and the chance to imitate the daffy judges on Iron Chef Japan. Yes please! Answering the invitation to judge the Taste Paradise Food Fight at the Port Douglas Carnivale, was impossible to resist. I had always wondered what it was like to judge a food event and I was about to see it first hand. Would my fellow judges and I agree? Would there be disagreement arguments about whose cuisine reigned supreme? Would there be vast ratings swings with many of us unable to decide a winner? What about collusion or bias? Well I had to see for myself!

Ricky Jordan of Bucci
The Port Douglas Carnivale is a celebration of the local food industry and the “Taste Paradise Food Fight” is one of the more fun events. It’s part of the local scene and we’ve all made it into today’s paper too and prior to the event I also did some radio interviews.

Evan Seaward of Bistro 3
The brief was simple. I along with my fellow judges wine and food critic Winsor Dobbin and chef Nick Holloway were to sample and judge two dishes made by some of Port Douglas’s leading chefs. There would be three rounds, the first two with four chefs each and the third round the deciding round with the two winners from the first two rounds facing off. Each chef would be challenged to cook in an unfamiliar environment with a surprising list of ingredients and an entree and main must be prepared within the 40 minutes allocated. In a twist, the chefs were given mystery boxes and each box had five ingredients in them. They needed to use at least two ingredients from the mystery box and the more they used the more points they would receive. They would receive ten points for each of these categories.
1. Difficulty of preparation and skill proficiency of each contestant(10 points)
2. The creative use of the ‘mystery’ ingredient and if what was originally planned has been prepared (10 points)
3. The innovativeness of the dish and how it relates to current cuisine trends (10 points)
4. How good the dishes taste and look (20 points)

Along with this we were also given a judging guideline which described what a score of 0-10 would involve and under which circumstances we should award the scores. Still since many of us were new to the whole judging process we were nervous although there was agreement that we wouldn’t discuss scores in case that created bias. We’re given our score card for each round with the chef’s names as we talk as the crowds gather. Each of us has a different background so we were curious to see whether our palates would rate things similarly or not. Only time would tell!

Vikas Chandra of the Sheraton Mirage
Round 1: The Gentlemen
Mystery box ingredients: cream, hard persimmons, cardamom pods, chillies and soft coconut meat.

Jed Sneddon of Nautilus
Enter the four chefs who nervously pace around their station. The crowd is mild mannered, it’s 5:30pm on a Friday and they’re politely awaiting some food fighting action. There are four cooking stations, each with two gas burners and a barbecue and there is a shared deep fat fryer, oven and hand wash facilities. Chefs are allowed to bring in cooking utensils, pots, pans, knives and appliances and any crockery to plate up on but are not allowed to bring any ingredients.

Behind the four cooking stations there is a huge fruit and vegetable display from Blood Orange, a local deli and a fridge full of meat, dairy and other assorted necessities, a pantry and a fish and seafood display by Coles which includes banana prawns, live mud crab (but very sleepy!) and several types of fish like red emperor, trevally and Spanish mackerel. The chefs are allowed to beg or borrow items from each other and they can keep going back to shop for more items after the initial shop. However there may not be enough of an item and it is on a first in first served policy although points are deducted for wastefulness!


The four chefs look nervous. We are sitting on the left hand side to them and after introducing them and us to the audience the two hosts, radio MCs Sal and Roy let them go for a shop. They’re surprisingly restrained and not in a hurry at all given the time constraints. They bring around their goodies to the station and we walk around and take a look and see how they are doing, what their knife skills are like, how messy and how ordered they are.

We note that one chef Vikas Chandra from the Sheraton has even written up plating instructions. Last year’s champion Tommy Young is on hand to defend the title in this round. Sal and Roy encourage the chefs as the crowd and we the judges look on. Any gaps in silence are punctuated by some bizarre Jamie Oliver sound bytes.

Dom Uhlig from Salsa
The 40 minutes goes surprisingly quickly for us and we’re just the judges – imagine how quickly this would go for the chefs! Before we know it, chef Dom Uhlig from Salsa is standing in front of us telling us about his two dishes.

Noodle salad
The three of us crowd around the dishes and we take some and put them on our plates to try them. The noodle salad was good although there was a bit of a presentation glitch when the lemon segment still had the sticker on it which prompted judge chef Nick to explain that if details like that are forgotten in his kitchen then one may wonder what else may have been forgotten. I found this a bit on the sweet side. With Thai and Asian style salads, there is that balance of sweet, sour, spicy and salty and this was a bit too sweet for me.

Lamb chops
The lamb chops are very well cooked and seasoned and come with a delicious mash, flaked almonds and greens. But no time to dawdle, we are tapping our pens onto the clipboard and writing down our scores before the second chef comes up to give us his dishes.

Jed Sneddon from Nautilus

Fritter
Chef Jed Sneddon of Nautilus is up next and he presents us with his two dishes. The first is a fritter and the texture is very soft and not crispy which is a surprise for us. It is paired with creamy exotic mushrooms.

Fish with salad
The fish is nicely cooked although Winsor finds the centre too raw for his liking but I do like the seasoning and the searing on the outside. It is paired with a salad which is a little tart for my liking and a creamy sauce as well as a couple of prawns.

Vikas Chandra from Sheraton Mirage

Grilled prawns served with salad of pomerieno, raw papaya and pomegranate with cream and green cardamom sauce
The third chef is Chef Vikas Chandra from the Sheraton Mirage and he presents us with a prawn dish. As soon as we all taste it we are in agreement, the seasoning for this is just right and the balance of flavour is great. The herbs used in it were very well balanced and the prawns had a good texture. There’s much scribbling and I’m curious to know how the other judges rated it but resist from peeking!
Read More