
I realise the title of this story sounds like one of those wonderfully magical children’s tales (and there is a little bit of a tale of a small child for you here too). The Ugly Cake that I speak of from Buppa’s Bakehouse in Newtown is not very ugly at all, despite the name. Buppa, a childhood nickname that stuck, contacted me a couple of weeks ago asking me if I would like to come in and taste her home baked goodies at her American style bakery, all made by her and her alone. I was in the throes of the flu (and no, not Swine Flu) and despite wanting to try them straight away, I begged off until my taste buds were back. They came back shortly after and I was looking forward to my visit.

Open for a mere 5 weeks, Buppa’s Bakehouse (Buppa rhymes with Papa) is on the quieter end of King Street in Newtown. In an elegantly hued building, it has a sparkling shopfront but you’d have to know it was there to find it amongst the jumble of shops. Buppa shows me her range of items and they’re certainly American in theme with peanut butter, chocolate and cream cheese featuring in many, cookies in many forms, all manner of American cakes and of course real boiled bagels - the New York way.
“My baking philosophy is that things should contain real ingredients, look delicious and be highly edible rather than just decorative. I am hoping that my ‘homemade’ style catches on and people start to remember what real cheesecake tastes like rather than the ones you can get that came out of a box, shipped from a warehouse etc.” she says. She’s more West Coast low key (actually San Franciscan) rather than the forward driven East Coast type.

Her story is interesting too – as the story goes she grew up very poor and to supplement the family’s income, her mum would enter baking contests but as there was a limit to the number of entries she could make, she entered under her children’s names. Buppa however was one of the 9 children that could cook so she entered her own goodies and ended up winning many prizes. The $5 for the children’s division and $10 for the adult’s division would prove a windfall for the family and set off a baking obsession for decades on and would urge her to quit her teaching job at an international school to open the bakehouse.

Blueberry bagel with cream cheese $4
I started with a blueberry bagel with cream cheese. She brings it out toasted and it’s generously spread with cream cheese. “It’s American style!” she says. “You’ve been to America right so you know that everything there is over the top and very generous in size” she says. The bagel is indeed a real boiled bagel with real blueberries (and her trick is to use dried blueberries which are costly but fresh ones are too soft). The cream cheese is thickly spread and some falls out as I bite in but it’s delicious. And yes it’s a bit more home made looking than bagels you may see which are made on a machine but that’s the point.

Pear & Plum Cheesecake $6
The baked cheesecake has small chunks of stewed cinnamon pears and plum and is topped with Beurre Bosc pears and cinnamon sugar. The filling is beautifully creamy and yet light. The buttery, crunchy crust is fantastic – possibly my favourite cheesecake crust ever and never discount the power of cheesecake crust. Get the wrong biscuit and it won’t be nearly as good.

Ugly Cake $7




























