Not Quite Nigella

Neapolitan Pizza Recipe For Pizza Oven

https://www.notquitenigella.com/2025/03/05/neapolitan-pizza-recipe

Neapolitan Pizza Recipe

Recipe Overview

An Original Recipe by Lorraine Elliott

Preparation time: 45 minutes plus 50 hours time

Cooking time: 2 minutes per pizza

Start this recipe 2.5 days ahead of time

Makes 3 x 28cm/11inch pizzas

Ingredients Needed

For the Dough

For Margarita Pizza

Step-By-Step Instructions

Image removed for printing
From this...

Day 1: Making the Poolish

Step 1 - Make the poolish. Take out 150g/5ozs out of the total flour and 150g/5flozs of the total water and mix with 1g/0.0.35oz of instant dried yeast in a medium bowl and mix well. Cover and allow to ferment overnight.

Image removed for printing
To this

Day 2: Making the Dough

Step 2 - Place the remaining 400g/14ozs of flour with the remaining 1g/0.0.35oz instant dried yeast making sure that the yeast is well distributed. Add in the 190ml/6.7flozs in a bowl and mix together along with the salt and sugar. Add in the poolish and stir together until you get a shaggy dough. Fit a mixer with a dough hook and knead on the lowest setting for 7-9 minutes or until you get a window pane effect where you can pull the dough apart slowly without tearing (with floured hands).

Image removed for printing
Window pane effect

Step 3 - Use a dough scraper and scrape the dough out onto a surface and grease a large bowl (I use the same mixer bowl). Shape into a ball and cover and allow to double the size. If it is cold where you are, place in a bowl of hot water, changing once or twice. This will take about an hour.

Image removed for printing

Step 4 - Weigh the dough. You should get 3x 290g/10.2oz balls of dough. Sprinkle a surface with flour and then fold each dough over from north to south, turning each time so that it gets four folds. Then shape it into a ball by cupping the dough with both hands and stretching it down into a tight ball. Then cup it on a surface and turn it slightly while cupping it. By the end you shouldn't have any cracks in the dough anywhere on the ball of dough. If there are any bubbles that pop up, prick them. Place in a large container with a lid and allow to rise in the fridge for 24 hours.

Image removed for printing
Before second ferment

Image removed for printing
After 24 hours fermentation

Day 3: Final Preparation and Cooking

Step 5 - 2.5 hours before you want to cook the pizzas take the dough out of the fridge and place the container on the counter. Have three shallow plates ready. After one hour, take each risen dough and reshape it. Repeat the same process as before - fold each dough over from north to south, turning each time so that it gets four folds. Then shape it into a ball by cupping the dough with both hands and stretching it down into a tight ball. Then cup it on a surface and turn it slightly while cupping it. By the end you shouldn't have any cracks in the dough anywhere on the ball of dough.

Image removed for printing

Image removed for printing

Image removed for printing
Cupping and shaping the dough into a round (bottom pic is showing finger positioning underneath the dough)

Image removed for printing
If the underside of the dough has cracks keep rolling the dough on a non-floured surface

Step 6 - Sprinkle a plate generously with flour going to the edges, not just the centre and place the dough ball on this. Place a bowl on top that will completely enclose it. Repeat with the remaining dough balls and allow it to rise around 1-2 hours. The dough will be ready when it reaches around 22C/71.6F.

Image removed for printing
Underside of dough with no big cracks-ready to go!

Step 7 - While the dough is rising, get the topping ingredients ready. Add the salt to the tomatoes and crush them with your hands. Cut the cheese into small cubes.

Step 8 - 45 minutes before you are ready to cook your dough, preheat your pizza oven. You are aiming for at around 480°C/900°F.

Shaping and Cooking the Pizza

Image removed for printing
Pressing the dough to stretch out

Step 9 - Sprinkle flour on a benchtop surface and take a pizza round and place it bottom side up (upside down) and add more flour there too. Keeping your dough as round as possible. Cup the dough around the edges to make it a circle. Rotate the dough pressing it out with your hands. With Neapolitan dough, you want to hold the dough down with your right hand and stretch it with your left hand (or vice versa, whatever you are most comfortable with). This takes practice so don't expect your pizza to be perfectly round the first time.

Image removed for printing
Holding dough down with one hand, stretching with the other, repeat

Step 10 - Spoon the tomato sauce on top with back of a large oval spoon. Tear the leaves of basil and place the basil underneath the small cubes of cheese.

Image removed for printing

Step 11 - Brush some semolina flour on a pizza peel and slide it onto the peel. You need to do this in one swift action in one direction. Usually I lift one side while Mr NQN slides it onto the peel with one swift forward motion. When it is on the peel reshape it again to keep it a circle (sometimes you have to do this, sometimes you don't).

Image removed for printing

Step 12 - When placing it in the pizza oven, slide it onto the heated pizza stone in one forward motion, not back and forth. Again this helps keep the round shape. Cook pizzas for around 60-90 seconds. Drizzle with olive oil and serve with extra basil if desired.

Image removed for printing
This post contains affiliate links. These help earn me a small commission at no added cost to you.

Speaking of saving, we used to get all of our fruit and vegetables delivered in a fortnightly delivery but I found it a bit too difficult with recipe testing not knowing what I was going to receive. It was a bit chaotic trying to finish everything in time too. So nowadays we go to the local Italian fruit and vegetable market. That way, I can get all the supplies that I need as well as the cheeses, charcuterie, pasta and pizza flour. But that means that Mr NQN has to come along because I don't want to carry at all even in a trolley. I mean seriously it's enough that I cook it all.

The first time that we went I pointed to some peaches and I asked him if he wanted some and he said, "No way they're too expensive". He kept saying no to things and then I realised it was because fruit was more expensive than the last time he went to the shops. I explained to him that we were going to spend $50-$60 there for a weeks worth of fruit and vegetables, and that's just the way that it is nowadays.

Image removed for printing

"I just have to not look at the prices, I guess," and after a while he'd stop wincing every time I put some mangoes, fresh berries or pizza flour into the trolley. I think for the last few years he was living in ignorant bliss! But he definitely knows how good the pizzas are and how much we are saving there. And it's not just because Teddy and Milo look at him like this when they come out of the oven.

So tell me Dear Reader, are you the person that does the shopping? How much do you spend a week on fruit and vegetables and for how many people?


Did you make this?

© Lorraine Elliott